Finance Ministry backs down on VAT

Fierce public objections about its proposal to impose value-added tax (VAT) on the transfer of land-use rights have forced the Ministry of Finance to shelve the move. 

In August last year, the ministry drafted a bill to amend and supplement articles of the tax law. Regarding VAT on land-use rights transfer, it proposed to tax it at the standard VAT rate of 10%.

This proposal immediately faced adverse reactions from the real estate sector. According to many experts, the increase of VAT will increase the price of properties and significantly affect the absorption rate of the market by putting a damper on housing demand.

Fierce public objections about its proposal to impose value-added tax (VAT) on the transfer of land-use rights have forced the Ministry of Finance to shelve the move (Photo: thanhnien.vn)
Le Hoang Chau, Chairman of HCM City Real Estate Association, told Phap Luat (HCM City Law) newspaper that imposing VAT could cause double taxation, which would push up land prices. Current taxes and fees applied to the transfer of land-use rights already include taxes on transfer of these rights, registration fees and personal income tax on sellers.

“The real-estate market ultilises thousands of products from more than 90 sectors, such as the manufacturing, construction and service sectors. Therefore, the imposition of VAT will lead to higher prices of raw materials and labour, lifting the price of houses,” Chau added.

Sharing the same idea, economist Ngo Tri Long said the newly-proposed VAT would put a massive burden on home buyers and the whole real estate market.

Nguyen Duy Minh, director of the L&L Group, agreed, saying that applying VAT would put real-estate businesses in difficulties, forcing them to increase house prices.

Therefore, he said the abolishment of the VAT would help stabilise the real-estate market. Stable tax policies help prevent houses price from fluctuating, encouraging people to invest more,” Minh said.

Economist Nguyen Tri Hieu said that applying VAT on the transfer of land-use rights would result in market fluctuations, indirectly affecting other sectors.

“Houses price increases would make people tighten spending. Real-estate companies would find it difficult to sell houses, would lose profits and the State would lose tax,” Hieu said.


Related

Financial Ministry rejects taxi association's call to slash VAT
Financial Ministry rejects taxi association's call to slash VAT

Vietnam’s finance ministry has turned down a request made by local taxi companies to lower taxes to form a fair and competitive environment in the ride services market.

Financial Ministry rejects taxi association's call to slash VAT

Financial Ministry rejects taxi association's call to slash VAT

Vietnam’s finance ministry has turned down a request made by local taxi companies to lower taxes to form a fair and competitive environment in the ride services market.

Low VAT rates in Vietnam benefit the rich more than the poor: WB
Low VAT rates in Vietnam benefit the rich more than the poor: WB

Despite widespread public opposition to raising VAT rates, a World Bank chief economist argues otherwise. 

Low VAT rates in Vietnam benefit the rich more than the poor: WB

Low VAT rates in Vietnam benefit the rich more than the poor: WB

Despite widespread public opposition to raising VAT rates, a World Bank chief economist argues otherwise. 

VAT refund process needs simplifying: experts
VAT refund process needs simplifying: experts

Experts have urged simplifying the procedures to receive refunds on value-added tax (VAT) for foreign tourists.

VAT refund process needs simplifying: experts

VAT refund process needs simplifying: experts

Experts have urged simplifying the procedures to receive refunds on value-added tax (VAT) for foreign tourists.